Are you looking for the perfect kitchen countertops for your home renovation project? Quartz and granite are both popular choices, but they have distinct pros and cons that make the granite countertops debate a hot topic among homeowners.
Both are premium stones you can use in your home. One stone is less heat resistant, while the other requires more maintenance. To help you choose between quartz counters vs granite countertops, we provided a list of pros and cons for both stones.
Before diving into the different pros and cons of granite and quartz countertops, here are a few things you should know about those countertop materials.
Quartz is a natural stone formed by crystalized silicon. It is the second most abundant material on Earth behind feldspar, making it an eco-conscious choice when remodeling. Natural quartz is known as quartzite, but most quartz countertops are made of engineered quartz consisting of crushed quartz bound with resin.
Granite is a highly resistant purely natural stone formed by cooling magma. It contains different minerals, including quartz and feldspar, giving its surface a unique aspect. It is mined in large slabs for countertop materials.
Choosing the right countertop material for your kitchen can be a tough decision. Quartz and granite are both popular choices, each with their unique advantages and disadvantages.
We’ve provided a quick comparison to help you decide:
| Quartz | Granite |
|---|---|
| Engineered stone (93% quartz, 7% resin) | 100% natural stone |
| Consistent, wide range of colors | Unique, natural patterns |
| Non-porous, low-maintenance, no sealing required | Porous, requires regular sealing |
| Resistant to scratches and stains, less heat-resistant | Highly durable, heat-resistant, prone to chipping and cracking |
| $80 to $150 per square foot installed | $80 to $180 per square foot installed |
| Increasing in popularity, but less than granite | High resale value, a favorite among homeowners |
Overall, while both quartz and granite offer attractive features, quartz stands out as the more practical and low-maintenance option for modern homeowners. Its non-porous surface, stain resistance, and vast array of design possibilities make it an excellent choice for a beautiful, hygienic, and worry-free kitchen.
When it comes to choosing between quartz and granite countertops, the appearance and color options are a major factor. Let’s take a closer look at each material:
Engineered quartz, made of a mix of crushed quartz and polymer resins, is a versatile material since it can be dyed any color. It can be crafted to resemble granite or marble or more unusual shades for a unique home improvement project. This engineered product offers a more consistent appearance that allows hiding seams better, especially for DIY installation. However, engineered quartz often looks less natural, so if you prefer the look of natural materials, it may not be the countertop material for you. Quartzite has a rougher texture that gives the slabs a more rustic look.
Since granite is a natural stone, each piece is unique, and you must carefully select the slabs to match each other when setting up your granite countertop. Granite countertops feature a wide variety of patterns based on the Earth’s whims and volcanic events that happened millions of years ago. Natural stone countertops may show seams, and you may need to compromise on the exact patterns and colors you envision or shop around to find the perfect candidate.
THE MOST NATURAL LOOKING: GRANITE
Explore Our Stunning Quartz Collection. Discover various colors, patterns, and styles in our curated quartz countertop collection.
When it comes to upkeep, quartz and granite countertops have distinct maintenance needs. Here’s a breakdown:
Engineered stone countertops like engineered quartz are as close to a maintenance-free surface as you can find. It is a non-porous surface and resists minor scratches thanks to the sturdy resin. It can be wiped clean with all-purpose cleaners or mild soap for a germ-free home and does not need to be sealed regularly. However, dark liquids may cause stains if they are not wiped clean rapidly. Quartz countertops have some heat resistance but will stain permanently when exposed to high temperatures, so it is best to use hot pads to protect them.
One of the differences between quartz and granite countertops is that the latest is a porous surface. Although a granite slab is a resistant surface, it requires some maintenance. This natural material must be sealed regularly to protect its beautiful appearance and durability. The surface must be polished without using harsh chemicals to avoid going through the sealing. If well maintained, your countertops using natural materials can last a lifetime.
THE EASIEST TO MAINTAIN: QUARTZ
Both quartz and granite are known for their durability, but they have distinct strengths and weaknesses. Let’s compare:
Both quartz and granite provide a durable countertop material for your house, and most quartz manufacturers offer a warranty for up to 10 years after installation. Since quartz is a non-porous surface, it is not as subject to staining. Besides, an engineered stone like granite countertops quartz is more flexible and less subject to breaking than natural materials. So-called engineered stone countertops can withstand everyday use and can be repaired with a special resin.
Granite countertops have some heat resistance and are scratch-resistant enough to avoid chipping from everyday use. However, since it is a porous surface, there may be staining unless spillages are cleaned with a specific cleaner. Granite slabs that are sealed regularly and well-maintained can last up to a hundred years, but since it is a natural stone, it may chip or crack.
THE MOST DURABLE: GRANITE
Both quartz and granite are known for their durability, but they have distinct strengths and weaknesses. Let’s compare:
Quartz countertops are considered to be a luxurious material since it is custom designed to the specifications of your house. Adding quartz countertops as a home improvement project can increase the resale value of your house, but it comes with a high cost. Quartz countertops start around $80 per square foot installed, but most cost around $110 per square foot and up to $150 for higher quality quartz granite.
There is a reason why granite countertops often appear on home buyers’ wish lists. This home improvement project adds to the resale value of your house and often pays for itself. When choosing between granite vs quartz, granite is the most cost-effective and usually costs around $130 per square foot installed, with a range between $80 and $180 per square foot plus installation.
THE MOST AFFORDABLE: QUARTZ
Both quartz and granite are considered high-end materials that can boost a home’s resale value, but they have different levels of appeal to potential buyers. Let’s see how they compare:
Quartz and granite are both high-end materials, but when it comes to quartz vs granite countertops, quartz is still a relative newcomer on the home improvement scene and does not have the same appeal. However, property hunters are becoming more interested in quartz countertops since this low-maintenance material does not need to be polished and resists staining better than natural stone.
The reputation of granite vs other materials such as wood, laminate, or engineered stone does not need to be made. Granite is one of the most popular countertop materials on the market and is a favorite among homeowners compared to other minerals when remodeling for resale for good reasons. When it comes to granite vs quartz for resale value, granite is a clear winner.
THE BEST RESALE VALUE: GRANITE
Quartz countertops have become increasingly popular in recent years, and for good reason. They offer a range of benefits that make them a compelling choice for homeowners. Let’s explore the key advantages:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Highly durable and long-lasting, making it a good investment. Stronger than natural stones like granite and marble. Flexible, making installation easier. | Less heat-resistant than granite. Temperatures exceeding 300°F can cause discoloration and cracking. |
| Low-maintenance. Doesn’t require annual sealing. Non-porous surface prevents spills from penetrating. Easy to clean with a sponge and warm water. | Not suitable for outdoor use. Can discolor when exposed to prolonged sunlight. |
| Consistent color and pattern across slabs. | Can have a more uniform appearance, sometimes leading to a “cookie-cutter” feel. |
Quartz is a highly reliable countertop material that’s durable and long-lasting, making it a good investment for homeowners. Quartz is also flexible which means installation is easier. This strength and flexibility come from its composition: 93% quartz and 7% resin. In fact, quartz is stronger than natural stones like granite and marble.
The resin in quartz makes it low-maintenance, and it doesn’t require annual sealing to prevent stains. The non-porous surface prevents spills from penetrating the material. Cleaning is simple: a quick wipe with a sponge and warm water keeps your quartz counter fresh.
Quartz is a manufactured stone, so there’s more consistency in color and pattern across slabs. Granite can have variations that lead to visible sealing marks when slabs are mismatched.
While quartz countertops offer many advantages, it’s important to be aware of their potential drawbacks. Here are a few things to consider:
Quartz can discolor when exposed to prolonged sunlight, so it’s best to use in indoor spaces like kitchens and bathrooms. While not a major concern for most homeowners, it’s important to note that quartz isn’t ideal for outdoor decks or patios. You might also want to avoid placing it in areas of your home that receive a lot of direct sunlight.
Quartz isn’t as heat-resistant as granite. Temperatures exceeding 300°F can cause discoloration and cracking. Consider using granite near your kitchen stove, especially if you have young children who might accidentally place hot pots or pans directly on the countertop. Sudden temperature changes can damage the surface.
Quartz, being a manufactured material, can have a more uniform appearance. This can sometimes lead to a “cookie-cutter” feel, as slabs tend to look similar. Granite offers unique and varied patterns, making each piece distinct.
Get Inspired by Real Quartz Transformations. See how quartz countertops elevate kitchens to new levels of style and function. Explore our project gallery and discover the possibilities for your own home.
Granite countertops have long been a popular choice for kitchens, and for good reason. They offer a unique blend of beauty, durability, and natural appeal that make them a timeless and practical investment. Each slab is a unique work of art, featuring one-of-a-kind patterns and colors that elevate any kitchen’s aesthetic.
Let’s explore the key advantages of choosing granite for your kitchen countertops:
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| 100% natural stone, mined specifically for countertops. Appeals to homeowners who value authenticity and quality. Unique patterns and colors create a timeless beauty. | Porous material, meaning it can absorb liquids. Requires regular sealing to prevent staining, chipping, and cracking. |
| High heat resistance. Can withstand hot pots and pans without discoloration or cracking. | Visible seams when multiple slabs are joined together. Matching veins and patterns can be challenging. |
| Resistant to high acids and bases. | Sealants can wear down over time, potentially leading to staining. Requires professional sealing appointments, adding to maintenance costs. |
Granite is a purely natural stone, mined specifically for use as countertops. It doesn’t rely on resins or other additives. This natural origin appeals to many homeowners who value authenticity and quality. The unique patterns and colors found in granite create a timeless beauty and a sense of natural elegance.
Granite countertops can withstand high heat. You can place hot pots or pans directly on the surface without causing discoloration or cracking. While it’s best to avoid doing this consistently, granite offers peace of mind when it comes to heat exposure.
Granite is resistant to high acids and bases. However, these substances can wear down the sealant over time, potentially leading to staining. Be sure to regularly seal your granite countertops to keep them protected and beautiful.
While granite countertops offer many advantages, it’s important to be aware of their potential drawbacks. Here are a few things to consider:
Granite is a porous material, meaning it can absorb liquids. This means if it isn’t sealed properly, it can harbor bacteria, potentially leading to health concerns. The sealant can wear down over time, especially around edges or areas of high impact. Additionally, the porous nature of granite makes it more susceptible to chips and fractures when exposed to sharp objects.
Granite countertops need regular sealing, typically annually, to maintain their protection and beauty. Sealing helps prevent staining, chipping, and cracking. This involves scheduling professional appointments, which can add to the overall maintenance cost.
Each slab of granite is unique, resulting in noticeable seams when multiple slabs are joined together. Matching the veins and patterns can be challenging, leading to a less uniform appearance.
Inspired by the Timeless Beauty of Granite? Witness the elegance and durability of granite countertops in a real-life kitchen transformation. Discover the unique patterns and colors that only nature can create.
Both granite and quartz countertops are high-value materials, but each has pros and cons. Do not hesitate to check out our selection of quartz countertop specials in Chicago and our granite countertop sale to find the most cost-effective materials for your next remodeling project.
If you have further questions about whether a quartz countertop or granite countertop is best for you, contact us for a free countertop consultation.
Most quartz countertops are made of engineered stone that is custom designed to fit your home by mixing resins with crushed quartz. Meanwhile, granite countertops are made of slabs of natural stone. Each slab is selected to match for a uniform look after on-site installation.
Granite and quartz are both desirable and very strong materials, but quartz countertops require less maintenance than the granite alternative. They do not need to be polished and are less subject to staining since it is not porous, unlike granite. It can also fit your kitchen better with room for the sink, etc.
When it comes to deciding on granite vs quartz based on the level of care and maintenance required, quartz is the winner since it is not porous, and the resins used to manufacture it do not need to be resealed. However, although both have some heat resistance, it is best to use hot pads to avoid cracks due to thermal shock or permanent stains.
Granite is a favorite among materials for kitchen countertops for good reasons. When properly maintained, following an installation by a professional, and if it is resealed regularly to keep it non-porous, this sturdy material can last a lifetime. Meanwhile, although quartz countertops are not porous, any damage to the finish may be permanent.
Although granite may be less porous than other natural materials such as wood, it can still be affected by moisture when subject to an environment like a bathroom. To avoid damage from spillage around the sink, quartz countertops, which are not porous, may be better suited for this site.
Do you have questions about granite or quartz countertops in Chicago?
Request a free consultation or visit our office.
