Solid Surface Countertops vs. Quartz Countertops: A Real-World Comparison
Kitchen remodeling decisions can feel overwhelming, especially when choosing between solid surface countertops and quartz countertops. Your neighbor might rave about solid surface material’s seamless look, while your contractor pushes quartz countertops for their durability. Both materials offer distinct advantages, but the right choice depends on your specific needs.
At Granite Selection, we’ve guided thousands of Chicago homeowners through this decision. Understanding the key differences between these countertop materials helps you choose confidently. This guide covers composition, performance, costs, and practical considerations to help you select the perfect fit for your kitchen and lifestyle.
What Is a Quartz Countertop? Pros and Cons.
Quartz countertops are engineered surfaces made from approximately 93% natural quartz stone combined with 7% resins and pigments. The manufacturing process involves crushing natural quartz crystals, mixing them with polymer resins, and subjecting the mixture to intense heat and pressure. The result: a non-porous, ultra-durable surface that looks like stone, without the maintenance of it.
Pros:
- Exceptionally durable and scratch-resistant
- Highly heat resistant, making it ideal for busy kitchens
- Available in a wide range of stone-like patterns and colors
- Never needs sealing
Cons:
- Seams can be visible, especially with intricate veining
- More expensive than solid surface
- Less flexible for custom edges or shapes
What Is a Solid Surface Countertop? Pros and Cons.
A solid surface countertop is a non-porous material made by combining mineral dust (like aluminum trihydrate or crushed marble) with resins and pigments. The mixture is poured into molds to create sheets, which are then shaped into finished countertops. This process gives it the flexibility to be used in curved or vertical applications, like backsplashes and integrated sinks.
Pros:
- Seamless look with inconspicuous joints
- Easier to shape or customize during installation
- Can be sanded to repair minor scratches or burns
Cons:
- Low heat tolerance — hot pans can scorch it
- Scratches more easily than quartz or granite
- Less visual depth compared to stone-like finishes
Quartz vs. Solid Surface: Side-by-Side Comparison
Choosing between these countertop materials requires understanding how they perform in real-world situations. While both quartz and solid surface offer excellent value, their distinct differences make each better suited for specific needs and preferences.
| Feature | Quartz Countertops | Solid Surface Countertops |
|---|---|---|
| Composition | 93% quartz + resin | 66% mineral dust + resin |
| Heat Resistance | Withstands moderate heat | Can scorch from hot pans |
| Scratch Resistance | Scratch resistant, less need for cutting board | Scratches easily, cutting board recommended |
| Seam Visibility | Visible seams, more so with patterns | Seamless appearance |
| Maintenance | Low; soap and water only | Needs polishing; easy DIY repairs |
| Customization | Standard shapes only | Curves, built-up edges, custom designs |
| Installation | Needs special tools | DIY-friendly with standard tools |
| Cost per sq ft | $50–$150 | $50–$200 |
| Repairability | Professional repair required | Sandable, easy to fix at home |
Color and Design Flexibility
Solid surface countertops offer unmatched design flexibility. The material can be shaped into virtually any form — curved edges, integrated drainboards, seamless backsplashes, and even vertical applications like shower surrounds. Solid surface material allows fabricators to create truly custom installations that are completely out of the box and as unique as you are.
Quartz countertops excel in replicating the beauty of natural stone countertops. Modern quartz surfaces can mimic granite, marble, and other natural stones with incredible realism. Some quartz trendy colors feature glass, marble chips, or metallic elements that create stunning visual depth.
Discover Premium Quartz at Unbeatable Prices
Looking for the perfect quartz countertops without breaking your budget? Our current quartz specials feature top brands at exceptional prices, helping you get the stone look you love for less.
Heat Resistance
When it comes to heat exposure, there’s a clear winner. Quartz countertops have much higher heat resistance compared to solid surface countertops. While you should always use trivets or cutting boards with hot pans, quartz can handle brief contact with moderately hot items without damage.
Solid surface countertops are prone to warping and scorching if hot items are placed directly on them. A hot pan straight from the oven can leave permanent damage on solid surface material. For busy families or serious home cooks, this difference can be significant.
Durability and Scratch Resistance
Both materials are highly durable, but in different ways. Quartz countertops tend to be more scratch-resistant due to their engineered stone composition. The natural quartz stone provides exceptional hardness that resists daily wear and scratches better than solid surface material.
Solid surface countertops can be scratched more easily — you’ll want to avoid cutting directly on the surface. However, here’s where solid surface shines: scratches can be easily sanded out and repaired. Minor damage to solid surface counters is essentially invisible after a simple repair, while quartz damage typically requires professional intervention.
Daily Maintenance Reality
Both materials are easy to clean day-to-day, but they differ in long-term upkeep. Solid surface countertops need mild soap and water for regular cleaning and occasional polishing to maintain their finish. Scratches and minor damage can be buffed out, giving you a surface that’s refreshable over time.
Quartz countertops require even less effort. Their non-porous surface resists stains and bacteria without sealing or special care. A simple wipe with mild detergent keeps them looking new, making quartz ideal for low-maintenance households.
Installation and Customization
Solid surface countertops offer significant advantages in customization and installation flexibility. The material can be cut by ordinary power saws and routers, and seaming kits allow for nearly invisible joints. Solid surface material can create truly seamless appearances, including integrated sinks and backsplashes.
Quartz countertops require special tools and professional installation. The material’s density makes it challenging to work with, and seams in quartz countertops, while minimal, are more visible than those in solid surface installations. However, even pre-cut quartz slabs deliver exceptional results when properly installed.
Seam Integration and Appearance
Seams tell a different story depending on the material. Solid surface countertops nearly erase them — fabricators fuse pieces so smoothly that seams vanish to the eye and touch, even across large spans.
Quartz countertop seams are more noticeable. While modern techniques minimize visibility, they can’t fully disappear, especially in patterned designs. Alignment matters, and in some layouts — like big islands or L-shapes — the seams may stand out more. Still, most homeowners find them subtle and easy to live with.
Food Safety and Hygiene Standards
Both materials score well for kitchen hygiene but do so differently. Solid surface countertops are non-porous throughout, so bacteria can’t penetrate. Their smooth surface resists microbial growth, and standard disinfectants easily wipe away any contamination.
Quartz countertops are also non-porous and have earned certification from the National Sanitation Foundation (NSF) for safe food preparation. The engineered surface resists moisture absorption completely, preventing bacterial growth and making cleanup straightforward. Many commercial kitchens choose quartz specifically for its hygienic properties combined with its durability under heavy use.
Cost Comparison: Budget vs. Long-Term Value
Understanding the true cost of countertop materials goes beyond the initial price per square foot. Both quartz and solid surface offer different value propositions depending on your budget, timeline, and long-term goals. Here’s how the costs compare across different scenarios:
| Cost Factor | Solid Surface | Quartz Countertops |
|---|---|---|
| Price per sq ft | $50–200 | $50–150 |
| 100 sq ft project | $5,000–20,000 | $5,000–15,000 |
| Long-Term Maintenance | Periodic polishing, cream wax polish | Minimal maintenance costs |
| Repair Costs | DIY-friendly, easily sanded | Professional repair required |
| Resale Value | Good value retention | Premium value, higher ROI |
Consider the total cost of ownership: solid surface countertops may incur additional maintenance costs due to periodic polishing requirements over time, while quartz countertops require minimal maintenance costs as they do not need to be sealed or polished regularly.
Get Your Exact Quartz Cost in Minutes
Wondering what your dream quartz countertops will actually cost? Our easy-to-use calculator gives you accurate pricing based on your specific measurements and style preferences.
Best Fit by Function: Which Countertop Works Where?
Different areas of your home have unique requirements that favor one material over the other. Understanding where each countertop material performs best helps you make decisions that enhance both functionality and aesthetics throughout your space.
Choose quartz countertops for:
- High-traffic kitchens: Busy family spaces that need maximum durability and scratch-resistant performance.
- Serious cooking spaces: Kitchens where heat-resistant qualities and low maintenance are essential.
- Long-term investments: Homes where resale value and premium materials matter most.
- Low-maintenance lifestyles: Households that prefer surfaces requiring minimal upkeep and no special cleaners.
- Natural stone aesthetics: Spaces where you want the beauty of granite or marble without the maintenance.
Choose solid surface countertops for:
- Budget-conscious remodels: Maximum value when cost per square foot is the primary concern.
- Covered outdoor kitchens: Resistant to moisture and seamless for exterior prep zones.
- DIY-friendly projects: Homeowners who want installation flexibility with ordinary power saws and standard tools.
- Rental properties: Durable, attractive surfaces that can be easily repaired and refreshed over time.
- Low-heat cooking environments: Kitchens focused on cold prep, baking, and minimal stovetop use.
Want to use quartz beyond the kitchen? It’s gaining popularity in places like showers and bath walls, too.
Ready to Choose Your Perfect Countertops?
There’s no universally “best” countertop material — only the best fit for your lifestyle, home, and peace of mind. Both solid surface and quartz countertops offer excellent performance and can enhance the look and feel of your kitchen.
At Granite Selection, we’ve helped thousands of Chicagoland homeowners navigate this decision. The key is understanding how you actually use your kitchen and what matters most to your family. Our team can show you exactly how each material performs and help you find the perfect match for your home. Contact us today for a free consultation and quote!
